Your locally owned independent
insurance agency based in Powell, Ohio
Serving your insurance needs with choices!

Serving the entire state of Ohio.
Click below to start your Experience

Request Quotes Customer Service

Great Agency. Always looks out for the best interest of my business and personal matters. I have been with them 10+ years now. Karen and her staff are very personable and I appreciate the consistency.
-Alexander Development Group

Karen has been our insurance agent / broker for several years. She’s always happy to explain & answer coverage questions. She finds the package best suited to our needs at the most competitive price.
-Happy Customer

I was really nervous signing up for another year of market place health insurance. Karen Niehaus patiently guided me through each and every step. She was amazingly thorough explaining each potential policy. I am 100% confident that I chose the one I wanted. It would have taken me days to do what we did in two hours. I have a better understanding of the market place now. I would highly recommend Niehaus Insurance Services to anyone applying for market place health or any other insurance. I am so happy and looking forward to going back to Niehaus Insurance Services next year. A genuine five star performance.
-John K.

I've been using Karen with niehaus insurance for five years now, she's basically like family now. She has always given us the best rates and she's always takes the time to explain things about the coverage and make sure I get the coverage that I need. I'm a penny-pincher and she's always helped me get the best deals for the coverage I need. I would definitely advise anybody to work with Karen, she and her associates are so nice and helpful.
-Wendy

Why should you get your insurance
from Niehaus Insurance Services?

We offer the widest range of products and pricing in Ohio.
Here’s why we’re different than the rest:

ohio insurance agency

Call Email Claims Payments
Skip to content